With the beginning of the Revolution in 1775, inhabitants
were forced to declare their political leanings; or hide them well. From
what has been written, it seems that Deer Isle was a divided community.
The majority were in favor of the new country. Those who openly defied the
British presence were in danger of being turned in by local "Tories" and
punished through forced labor details, whippings and ostracism. Many residents
were forced to build up the British defenses at nearby Castine, or "working
out their tour," as described by Hosmer. The British commanding the area
required either a pledge of allegiance or neutrality to the crown from all
area residents. Though there were undoubtedly many loyalists, there are many
more defiant colonials on record. William Eaton and others refused to take
an oath of loyalty and left. Vernal Hutchinson, who as well as his Civil
War narrative wrote a volume that documents the region during the Revolution,
names a dozen residents as serving in the Continental Army; from the siege
of Boston on. Some of the more notable were Caleb Haskell, who was in the
ranks of Benedict Arnold’s ill-fated 1775 expedition into Quebec, Joseph Tyler
and George Grouse who fought at Saratoga and Courtney Babbidge who was on
hand at Cornwallis’s surrender at Yorktown. The only fighting that occurred
in the region was at Castine in 1779. A poorly executed plan designed to
take the British fort by amphibious assault proved a complete failure. Over
30 Deer Isle men were involved in the colonist’s raid. It has not been recorded
how many fought from within the Castine defenses. This minor fight would
be the only regional threat posed to the empire’s comfortable hold on the
Maine coast during the Revolution. Yet with Cornwallis’s stunning capitulation
in 1781, local loyalists were quite suddenly without a country. The British,
per terms that officially ended the war, gave up their sovereignty over the
colonies. Loyalists, now fearful of reprisals or unwilling to accept the
new government, packed up and moved out; taking up residence in the "Provinces."
Many areas of northeastern Canada can trace their lineage directly to this
influx of Tory refugees in the early 1780s; Saint John and Fredericton in
New Brunswick and Shelburne in Nova Scotia being towns that were literally
created from this exodus. Yet to those who’d cast their lot with the American
cause went the spoils. And Deer Isle was a rich reward.
Marriage: Jane b: 1710 in Liberton, Midlothian, Scotland
Married: 1731 in Liberton, Midlothian,
Scotland
Children:
1. James Greenlaw b: Abt 1732 (Has Children)
2. *Jonathan Greenlaw b: 1736 in Liberton, Edinburgh,
Scotland (Has Children)
3. William Greenlaw Jr. b: 1738 in Liberton, Edinburgh,
Scotland (Has Children)
4. Charles Greenlaw b: 1743 in Liberton, Edinburgh,
Scotland (Has Children)
5. Ebenezer Greenlaw b: 1740 in Liberton, Edinburgh,
Scotland (Has Children)
6. Alexander Greenlaw b: 1748 in Liberton, Edinburgh,
Scotland (Has Children)
His six sons were whigs. They
went to St. Andrew, N. B., in 1783. Jonathan, Ebenezer, and Alexander were
captured as POW's when they sailed to deliver cattel brought
down in the sloop from Penobscot under the date of June 20, 1784 in
support of British Troops. Separate charges appear against each of the men,
with mention of the number of cattle and other live stock brought for each.
Sources:
American loyalists, biog. sketches of adherents to the British crown in
the War of the Rev. By Lorenzo Sabine. Boston. 1847. (733p.): 336-7
Volume: 67 Page Number: 343
See also: Divided
Hearts, Massachusetts Loyalists, 1765-1790 (Orig. Pub. by The Society of Colonial
Wars in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and The New England Historic
Genealogical Society, Boston, MA. David E. Maas, Divided hearts,
Massachusetts loyalists, 1765-1790 : a biographical directory,
1980).
Muster Roll of Capt. Thomas MILLER’s Company from 25th October to 24th December 1781
Captain Thomas MILLER
Lieutenant James McDONALD
Ensign Thomas MILLER
In Europe
Sgt James GRANT
Sgt John McKAY
Sgt John McKINNEY
Transfer’d to Capt.
VERNON’s Troop
25 Octr. 1781
Sgt John DIXON
Dead
20 Octr. 1781
Sgt William MILLER
Taken Prisoner
23 Feby. 1780
Cpl Thomas SCOTT
at Charlestown
Neil CAMPBELL
do
Angus CHRISTY
William GRANT
Ronald McDONALD
at Charlestown
Alexander FRAZER
Charles STEWART
at Charlestown
Daniel INNES
James ROBERTSON
Genl. Hospital New
York
Joseph GILL
George MILLER
Alexander FORBES
Invalided
24 Augt. 1781- his pay to be retd.
Donald McLEOD
do
do
do
John McBEAN
A Prisoner 23 Feby. 1781 and died 5 Octr. 1781
William FORBES
Taken Prisoner 23 Feby. 1781
Angus GRAHAM
do
do
James GEDDES
do
do
William GREENLAW
do
do
Hugh HOOD
do
do
John INGOLSBY
do
do
Alexander LESLIE
do
do
John McKENZIE
do
do
Norman McLEOD
do
do
Peter STEWART
do
do
James SMITH
do
do
Duncan CAMPBELL
do
do
James GLASS
do
do
William STEWART
do
do
Charles HORSFIELD
do
25 Augt. 1779
Thomas McDONALD
do
25 April 1780
James LOGAN
Dead 24 June 1781
Torquin McLEOD
Discharged
23 Feby. 1781
Robert REID
Dead 16 April 1781
William McDONALD
Taken Prisoner 23 Feby.
1781
John WYLY
Henry FORBES
John POLLOCH
Dead 24 Augt. 1781
Peter REDDOCH